The time has come; It is the final stop on the Plant Based Food Tour of Princeton. This week we’ll be hitting up a variety of restaurants. We’ll give you our take on ice cream, pizza, and fully plant-based restaurants. Have you been curious about dairy free options at local ice cream shops, but still too nervous to take the leap? We will convince you! Wondering how pizza can be vegan? You’ll be surprised. Overwhelmed by all the different options at the local juiceries and plant-based restaurants? We’ll help you figure out what’s best for you. While this may be the final stop, we hope that we’ve encouraged you to continue to pick plant-based options when dining out in Princeton and wherever else you go. You can do something good for both your body and the planet!
Sweets
Thomas Sweet – Most Likely to Make You Feel Like a Kid Again
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★
Creativity: ★★★
Plant Forward: ★★
Taste: ★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★
Thomas Sweet is most well-known for its blend-ins, which are a variety of toppings that you can get mixed with ice cream in a special machine to create a soft serve-like consistency. Because I wanted to sample the shop’s vegan options, however, I wasn’t able to get any of the flavors that were available for blend-ins. Their only vegan offerings were two flavors of sorbet: watermelon and pineapple. I ordered a single scoop of the watermelon, which I thought had a bit of an artificial candy-like flavor. The texture of the sorbet was quite enjoyable, though; I was expecting something like Italian ice and so was pleasantly surprised by how smooth it was. While Thomas Sweet may not be the best place to go if you’re looking for vegan frozen desserts, the blend-ins looked super fun, and I would definitely recommend giving them a try if you eat dairy. The store is not too far from campus and there are some outdoor tables right outside, perfect for a sunny outing with a few friends. I also loved how charming it was inside, with bright colors, whimsical decor, and even a funhouse mirror. Overall, Thomas Sweet is my ideal childhood ice cream shop with some creative twists!
Bent Spoon – Most Vegan-Friendly Ice Cream in Princeton
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★
Creativity: ★★★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★★
Taste: ★★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★
Bent Spoon will never fail to surprise you with their creative flavors. This holds true when it comes to their plant-based options. Their vegan flavors currently entail dark chocolate, raspberry, mango, organic coconut, cookies and cream, blood orange, and coffee coconut. I tried the organic coconut, cookies and cream, blood orange, and coffee coconut. I was thoroughly impressed with them all, but I think my favorite was the coffee coconut. Most ice cream shops typically only offer sorbets as their dairy-free options, so I love that Bent Spoon offers some more traditional, creamy/milky dairy-free options such as cookies and cream. Their creamier, more traditional ice creams seam to be coconut-based, so if you like coconut, this is perfect! They also hit it out of the park with sorbets if you are looking for a fruity, summer vibe. Regardless of what you’re in the mood for, if you are looking for plant-based ice cream, Bent Spoon has you covered.
Halo Pub – Creamiest Ice Cream in Princeton
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★★
Plant Forward: ★★
Taste: ★★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★
Overall, I had a really great experience at Halo Pub, but it did come with some disappointments for the vegan in me. I was disappointed to discover that their sorbets still had dairy in them and they were all out of their dairy-free flavors (but I will definitely return to try the dairy-free when they are back!). Because of this, I ended up ordering cookie dough and M&M ice cream which were both absolutely delicious! That said, as I’m writing this a couple hours later, I’m definitely having stomach pains. I would say the deliciousness was definitely worth it for me, but if you are more strict with your plant-based diet, be sure to go when their dairy free flavors are available!
Pizza
Jules Thin Crust – Most Likely to Challenge Your Notion of Pizza
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★
Taste: ★★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★★
Jules Thin Crust doesn’t just provide your simple cheese pizza — indeed, they offer an impressive number of coded options and toppings from which you can choose! While many of their options are cheese-based or include meat, they also present several vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, including many no-meat pizzas, one vegan option, custom pizzas, and vegan cheese substitutes. After perusing their menu online, I ordered a mini Mexican pizza and a field salad with balsamic dressing. It took me just a minute to walk from the gates to pick up my food! The mini pizza was equivalent to about 2 slices of a large pizza, and at $8.25, was pretty good value for all the toppings you get: tomatoes, corn, scallions, cilantro, mozzarella, and chipotle sour cream, all on top of a delicious black bean spread on a crispy thin crust! Although the cilantro was a bit overpowering, the fresh tomatoes and sour cream really complemented the black beans well. The organic salad, albeit a bit pricey at $9.25, was well-sized and flavorful. The dried cranberries, apples, goat cheese, and balsamic were pretty standard additions but nonetheless delicious! Overall, I was pleasantly surprised by Jules’ Mexican pizza, and would definitely try their other special, non-cheese pizzas again.
Pizza Den – Most Plant-Friendly Pizza Place
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★
Taste: ★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★
Overall, my experience at Pizza Den was really great. I ordered a Tomato Pie, which had no cheese, making it vegan and absolutely delicious! I also ordered the Brooklyn Pie which was even more delicious with a fluffy crust, a lot of sauce, and only small pieces of whole mozzarella (which is great for the plant-based eater like me who will eat cheese sometimes but doesn’t want so much that it will make her stomach hurt!). They also have the option to use daiya cheese (vegan cheese) which I love for the dairy-free and pure vegans out there! Last, I ordered the Nutella and banana dessert pizza. I’ve never had a dessert pizza before and I really enjoyed the sweet treat! I also ordered it all through Snackpass and was able to get a discount code so the ordering process was seamless and the price was right!
Fully Plant-Based
Fresca Bowl
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★★
Taste: ★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★★
Fresca Bowl offers almost an overwhelming variety of options. Not only do they offer a variety of plant-based bowls (acai, pitaya, kale, chia, and oatmeal), but they also have smoothies, toast, salads, soups, coffee, and poke bowls. I tried the Fresca Acai bowl, the Pesca Noce toast, and Green Machine smoothie. The Fresca Acai bowl was not only delicious, but I was very satisfied with how large the bowl was. It was densely packed with fruits, granola, nutella, and acai, leaving me feeling very full. I feel that sometimes restaurants skimp out on the acai bowl, but Fresca Bowl certainly does not! They have a variety of toasts, both savory and sweet, but the Pesca Noce is a sweet toast with peaches, cream cheese, granola, honey, chia seeds, and cinnamon. It was also really filling and delicious. I highly recommend treating yourself for breakfast or even dessert with the Pesca Noce toast. Last but not least, I tried the Green Machine smoothie. Don’t be afraid to get your daily greens in; this smoothie was delicious and still pretty sweet, despite the main ingredients featuring both kale and spinach. Fresca Bowl is a great and convenient stop to get you plant-based fixings in and they have lots to offer. Maybe too much if you’re the indecisive type!
Playa Bowls – Most Colorful Smoothie and My Favorite Acai Bowl
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★
Creativity: ★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★★
Taste: ★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★
For the last stop on my plant-based food tour, I went to Playa Bowls. There I got a Pura Vida açai bowl and a pitaya smoothie. The açai bowl surpassed my expectations. It had the sweetness of honey, fruitiness of açai, blueberries, and strawberries, and the crunch of delicious granola. It was nicely cold and I recommend it. The smoothie didn’t quite meet how delicious it looked. Being a bright pink pitaya mixture, I expected lots of fruity flavor. What I got was nicely creamy, but not very flavorful. It was very far from the sweetness, acidity, or kick usually present in a good fruit smoothie.
I love the inside of Playa Bowls. It is located on Hullfish Road next to Lan Ramen and down the street from the public library. I was asked whether or not I wanted a bag and I did not receive any unnecessary plastic or waste. The plastic smoothie cup claims to be made of recycled plastic and the shop advertises their commitment to reducing waste. I recommend ordering the Pura Vida or another açai bowl the next time you go to Playa Bowls.
Tico’s – Most Fantastically Fruity Flavours
Price: $
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★★
Plant Based: ★★★
Taste: ★★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★
Got a sweet tooth? Love you some fruit? Want to combine the two? Look no further than the astounding establishment that is Ticos! Located on Spring Street, Ticos is a Princeton town stalwart that is totally worth your time. For this review I ordered their Pina Colada smoothie and the Sweet Thing organic bowl, both of which were packed with fruity goodness and left me very satisfied long after the food had disappeared. I have never tried a smoothie bowl with a guava base before and the Sweet Thing bowl really impressed me. The Pina Colada smoothie is my go-to when ordering at Tico’s and I cannot rave about it enough. The menu at Tico’s is mostly fruit items, but you can order quesadillas as well. There is a large range of plant-based options, but keep in mind that all of their smoothies contain yoghurt, so if you are searching for a wholly vegan option you will have to ask them to substitute the yoghurt for ice. I have never had a bad experience at Ticos and I doubt you will either; go on… Check it out!
Planted Plate – Most Plant-Based Plate in Princeton
Price: $$
Bang for Your Buck: ★★★★
Creativity: ★★★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★★
Taste: ★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★★★★
Wow. So many plant-based options to choose from. My personal favorite was the cauliflower bites. They would certainly satisfy a buffalo wing craving anyday. The vegan ranch was also a wonderful dipping sauce. I was surprised by the pitas served with the hummus; they were warm and both crispy and soft. 10/10 would recommend. The main dish I had was the cali burger, which was good, but a little dry. The bread and toppings were, however, very fresh and I felt like I was eating good, quality ingredients. Hot take: Planted Plate has the best french fries in Princeton. I also learned that if you’re on snack pass you can get 25% your first order at Planted Plate and if you’re a student you can get 10% off anytime!
Arlee’s Raw Blends – Best at Making the Ingredients Shine
Price: $$
Bang for Your Buck: ★★
Creativity: ★★★★★
Plant Forward: ★★★★★
Taste: ★★★★
Ease of Access: ★★
While the focus at Arlee’s might be on juices, don’t be deceived—they have a surprising amount of variety in their menu items, including breakfast items, wraps, salads, snacks, desserts, and even pizza. Furthermore, everything is completely plant-based! My sweet tooth was calling and I was especially enticed by their plant-based cheesecake, so I ordered two slices, one strawberry and one mango. For my daily caffeine fix, I also got a cold brew latte made with almond milk. As a big fan of fruity desserts, the cheesecake was right up my alley. It was lighter than traditional cheesecakes but still had a nice tang, and the crust made from raw almonds actually resembled a graham cracker crust more than I expected. I personally liked the strawberry better than the mango, but would happily take another slice of either! One note is that you should avoid letting the cheesecake sit for too long—I left it at room temperature for a few hours before finishing it, and the texture softened a lot once it was no longer chilled. The cold brew latte was sweet but refreshingly so, with a pronounced cinnamon taste. It did seem a little watery to me, especially because I tend to like strong coffee drinks. That being said I finished it easily (and also loved the glass bottle it came in!). One drawback is that the items at Arlee’s can be quite pricey ($8.99 for each slice of cheesecake and $10.99 for a 16oz. latte). While perhaps not affordable on a regular basis, and also a little far from campus (near Hoagie Haven), the quality of the ingredients at Arlee’s and its exciting plant-based menu make it a great place for a special treat.
*** We are not food critics, but food enthusiasts. This is in no way intended to be a formal critique or review of any restaurant in Princeton, merely a way to encourage students to try more plant-based options when dining out.